When it comes to curb appeal, few decisions impact your home exterior as much as choosing the right siding materials. When considering steel vs. vinyl vs. LP SmartSide costs, you of course need to look at upfront material prices. But you should also factor in each option’s installation costs, long-term upkeep, and unique benefits and expected lifespan.
This guide takes a look at all of that so you can get a view into the true lifetime value of steel, vinyl, and LP SmartSide siding. That way you can make an informed decision that works best for your needs.
The Initial Investment: Steel vs. Vinyl vs. LP SmartSide Costs
When considering options for exterior siding, either as a replacement or for new construction, the logical first step is to look at the cost to purchase and install the materials. While this is only the beginning factor in the entire formula, it will likely be a major element of the total cost.
Steel Siding
Steel siding material costs typically range from $4.25–$8.25 per square foot. It comes pre-painted and with a UV protective coating.
When it comes to installation, you can either go DIY or hire a professional installer. If you hire a contractor, you can expect installation to account for 50-55% of total project costs. The process usually takes 2-4 weeks for an average home. Proper installation is essential to maximize steel’s durability and weather-resistance benefits.
Vinyl Siding
Vinyl siding remains one of the most affordable siding products on the market. At $4.50–$8.20 per square foot for materials, vinyl offers an attractive entry point for budget-conscious homeowners.
Vinyl installation is relatively straightforward, making it a popular DIY project for handy homeowners. Professional installation typically takes 1-2 weeks for an average home, with labor costs accounting for roughly 50% of the total project expense.
The simplicity of vinyl installation stems from its lightweight nature and interlocking panel design. However, proper installation is important to prevent future issues with moisture infiltration and panel separation.
LP SmartSide
LP SmartSide is a type of engineered wood siding produced by bonding wood fibers and strands with heavy-duty resin. It typically costs between $4.50 and $11 per square foot for materials. Keep in mind, for the lower-priced panels, they come primed but will need to be painted after installation, which will add to the cost.
LP SmartSide siding requires more skill to install due to its weight and need for precise cutting. Professional installation typically takes 1-2 weeks, plus another week if painting is required. Installation costs for LP SmartSide generally account for about 40-60% of the total project price.
The installation process requires proper caulking at seams and careful attention to manufacturer guidelines. While some experienced DIYers tackle LP SmartSide installation, most homeowners benefit from professional installation to ensure the product’s warranty remains valid.
The Long-Term Value of Steel, Vinyl, and LP SmartSide
The steel, vinyl, and LP SmartSide cost considerations don’t stop at materials and installation. You should also consider their long-term value in terms of durability, maintenance, overall lifespan, and energy efficiency.
Durability and Maintenance
Steel is the low maintenance, high durability option. It resists denting, warping, and fading. Steel siding also won’t succumb to mildew, and provides excellent fire resistance. You won’t have to do more than rinse it down with a hose to keep it looking its best. These are all qualities that translate to significant long-term savings.
Vinyl is low-maintenance, but is also less durable than both steel and LP SmartSide. It doesn’t require repainting and is resistant to mildew, termites, and rot. However, it’s susceptible to warping, denting, fading, and damage from extreme weather conditions, which can lead to higher long-term expenses.
LP SmartSide is in the middle ground for maintenance and durability. It’s designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, offering excellent impact resistance. LP SmartSide is also less susceptible to mildew and termites compared to natural wood. However, it does require caulking touchups and repainting every 5-7 years to maintain its appearance and prevent moisture issues.
Lifespan
When it comes to lifespan, vinyl and LP SmartSide are comparable, and steel comes out as the winner in this category.
- Steel siding lifespan: 40-70 years
- Vinyl siding lifespan: 20-30 years, but can be as short as 10 years in some areas
- LP SmartSide lifespan: 20-30 years
The longer your siding’s lifespan, the longer you can go before having to replace it, which contributes to your overall return on investment.
Energy Efficiency
All three siding options can contribute to your home’s energy efficiency, but their performance varies:
- Vinyl siding offers moderate insulation value, especially with insulated backing.
- LP SmartSide provides better natural insulation than vinyl due to its wood-based composition.
- Steel siding, when installed with proper insulation, delivers excellent thermal performance and can significantly reduce heating and cooling costs.
The energy savings from premium siding options can offset their higher initial costs over time, particularly in regions with extreme temperatures.
Steel vs. Vinyl vs. LP SmartSide Costs: A Side-by-Side Comparison Chart
| Siding Type | Material Cost | Durability | Lifespan | Maintenance | Energy Efficiency |
| Steel | $4-$8/sq. ft. | High | 40-70+ years | Low, will only needed rinsed with a hose | High |
| Vinyl | $4.50- $8.20/sq. ft. | Low | 20-30 years | Low, will only require occasional cleaning | Low |
| LP SmartSide | $4.50-$11/sq. ft. | Medium | 20-30 years | Moderate, paint and caulk needed every 10 years | Medium |
FAQs About Steel, Vinyl, and LP SmartSide
No matter what style of home you own, when comparing siding options, it is important to consider not just the initial costs but also the long-term benefits and maintenance requirements. Let’s look at a few of the most-asked questions from homeowners when considering exterior siding options.
Is LP SmartSide More Expensive Than Vinyl?
Yes, LP SmartSide is generally more expensive than vinyl siding in terms of both materials and installation. However, its enhanced durability and curb appeal can justify the higher initial investment for many homeowners.
What’s More Cost-Effective Over Time — Vinyl or LP SmartSide?
While vinyl siding is the most affordable upfront, it may incur higher costs over time due to its susceptibility to fading and denting. LP SmartSide, with its durability and moderate maintenance, can be more cost-effective in the long run despite the higher initial cost.
How Do Vinyl and LP SmartSide Compare to Steel Siding?
Compared to vinyl and LP SmartSide, steel siding offers the highest durability and lowest maintenance requirements, making it a superior choice for homeowners seeking long-term value. Plus, with the initial investment comparable to vinyl and LP SmartSide, the benefits of reduced upkeep, enhanced energy efficiency, and increased lifespan make steel siding a wise investment for your home.
It’s More Than Just Material Costs
Choosing the right siding for your home involves evaluating upfront costs, installation expenses, and long-term maintenance and durability.
- Vinyl siding is budget-friendly and easy to install, but doesn’t last as long.
- LP SmartSide offers the beauty of natural wood with enhanced durability, making it a cost-effective choice in the long run if you don’t mind repainting it every 7-10 years.
- Steel siding, with its exceptional durability, fire resistance, ease of maintenance, design styles, and energy efficiency, offers the best long-term value.
Whether you’re updating your home or building new, high-quality steel siding from TruLog is the hands-down choice when looking at true value for the investment. Plus, you don’t have to sacrifice the look of wood. TruLog is available in lap, log, and board and batten styles in a variety of woodgrain finishes.
Download TruLog’s catalog to discover the wide range of available styles that will add both strength and beauty to your home for many decades to come.
